Inner critic
Your inner critic is not your enemy
The voice that never lets up isn’t trying to ruin your life. It’s doing an old job, badly. Here’s how we start to give it a rest.
Most people arrive in therapy able to describe their inner critic in vivid detail. It has a tone. It has favourite phrases. It tends to get loudest at particular times — before sleep, after a social event, the moment before you try something new.
What surprises people is the suggestion that this voice started out as protection. Somewhere earlier in your life, being hard on yourself first was safer than being caught out. If you noticed every flaw before anyone else could, you stayed one step ahead. If you kept your expectations low, disappointment couldn’t knock you down.
The inner critic learned that keeping you small kept you safe. It has never been told the danger has passed.
Why arguing with it doesn’t work
When the critic says “you’re not good enough,” the instinct is to fight back with evidence: the qualifications, the people who value you, the things you’ve managed. It rarely helps for long. The critic isn’t really making an argument — it’s expressing fear. You can’t reason someone out of a feeling they were never reasoned into.
What tends to shift things is a change of relationship rather than a change of content. Instead of “is this true or false,” we get curious: how old does this voice sound? Whose words are these, originally? What is it afraid will happen if it stops?
What we do instead, in sessions
- Notice the critic as a separate voice, not the whole of you — “a part of me thinks…” rather than “I am…”
- Trace a few of its lines back to where they were first said, and by whom.
- Practise responding the way you would to a frightened friend: acknowledging the worry without obeying it.
- Let the kinder, steadier voice get some practice too. It’s usually underused.
None of this makes the critic vanish. The aim is smaller and more durable: it stops being the only voice in the room, and you stop taking every word as fact.